Home / Books / Book Review: The Mephisto Covenant by Trinity Faegan

Book Review: The Mephisto Covenant by Trinity Faegan

I love this cover- although it’s completely and utterly unrelated to the novel! I guess it just goes to show, you shouldn’t judge a book by its cover…

Book Review: The Mephisto Covenant

GoodReadsAmazonAuthor Website

The Mephisto Covenant by Trinity Faegan

Title & Author: The Mephisto Covenant: The Redemption of Ajax by Trinity Faegan

Genre: YA- Paranormal

Release Date: September 27, 2011

Series: 1st in a planned series

Publisher: EgemontUSA

How I Got the Book: ARC via NetGalley

Description: “Sasha is desperate to find out who murdered her father. When getting the answer means pledging her soul to Eryx, she unlocks a secret that puts her in grave danger—she is an Anabo, a daughter of Eve, and Eryx’s biggest threat.

A son of Hell, immortal, and bound to Earth forever, Jax looks for redemption in the Mephisto Covenant—God’s promise he will find peace in the love of an Anabo. After a thousand years, he’s finally found the girl he’s been searching for: Sasha.

With the threat of Eryx always looming, Jax knows he has to keep Sasha safe and win her over.  But can he? Will Sasha love him and give up her mortal life?”

Zero to Sixty in 10 Pages

I know a lot of people say this, but I really wanted to like this book. I featured it awhile ago on a Waiting on Wednesday post and was so stoked about the plot and the cover. For me, this book didn’t deliver in a couple of key areas.

I’ll start with the pacing first. In the first 15 pages of the book, readers are barraged with tons of action- I’m talking group killings, evil cult meetings and CIA cover ups. It’s all way too much!

Plus, the back story is relatively involved but isn’t explained until several chapters into the book. There are Sons of Hell who take lost souls (people who’ve pledged their spirits to Eryx- a minion of Lucifer who’s trying to take over hell) and people called Anabo who are born without the temptation to sin. A lot has to be explained to make sense, but readers are left hanging for a good part of the book.

Towards the middle of the book, the pacing becomes more consistent and lets the readers catch their breath a little.

Religion: The Good and the Bad

This is so tough for me because when I don’t like something about the plot or story of a book, it’s normally a minor thing. With The Mephisto Covenant, I didn’t connect with the whole idea behind the novel.

For me, if religion is in a book it has to be done well. There should be a system in place that makes sense- either something that’s fully fleshed out (ex: The Girl of Fire and Thorns) or a simple sort of faith that pops up once and awhile (ex: Waterfall). The Mephisto Covenant had strange rules that weren’t consistent.

For example, someone could devote themselves to a demon like Eryx through a pledge and lose their soul forever. Even though they didn’t technically do anything wrong themselves. Yet, the Anabo that exist are people who are righteous and perfect through no effort of their own and virtually can’t sin no matter how hard they try- they’re simply born that way (cue Lady Gaga music).

Doesn’t that seem a little unbalanced to you? It was familiar enough to Christianity that I would begin to feel comfortable but then it would add a twist of something so foreign that I was reeling.

Also, the ending of the book was just plain disappointing. It didn’t fit with story, and I was left feeling unhappy and dissatisfied.


For maybe the first time ever, I have to honestly say that I cannot recommend this book. From the overload of information in the beginning to the lackluster end, The Mephisto Covenant was a mess. Read at your own risk.

About Lisa Parkin

I'm a hardcore lover of young adult fiction and have been reviewing books since 2011. Other interests include Downton Abbey, heat lightning storms, Harry Potter land and (begrudingly) one orange tabby.
  • Truly Bookish

    From the summary I knew this one was not for me, thanks for confirming. The cover really is awesome! BTW, the same model (in the same dress, just Photoshoped into red) is used for the Australian cover of Unearthly: http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9828218-unearthly
    Truly Bookish

  • Ems

    Oh dear. I have this one in my NetGalley queue and was going to get started soon. Hmmm…might have to put it off and steel myself for disappointment. Excellent review!

    • Thanks Ems. Yeah, I mean, I’d def be interested to see what you think, but I’d hate for you to dislike it too :/

  • “… The Mephisto Covenant was a mess.” <– My thoughts EXACTLY. And the religion thing really threw me off too. It was like some sort of bastardized version of Christianity and just didn't sit well with me.

    • I totally agree- it just continued to throw me off. We tried, though, Jinny- we really did 😉

  • I wasn’t sure what to think of this one from the description, but it sounds like it won’t be for me, either. I have a hard time with religion in books, especially when it seems like bits and pieces of real religions. Thanks for the honest review.

  • oodlesofbooks

    The title alone steered me away from this book, but I still considered giving it a chance in the future. Not sure if I will ever get to it though, and I after reading your review, I don’t feel so bad about that. Thanks for your honesty. Awesome review!

  • Melissa Hayden

    So sorry to hear the book didn’t do well for you. I have to say I love the cover. 🙂 It’s beautiful.

    I’m not one big on religion in books, but I love a quick start. Just doesn’t sound like it worked well together for you. Sorry because I know you really wanted to love this one.

  • Bummer. It’s such a gorgeous book. Thank you for your honest review.

  • Sorry you didn’t like it! I had originally requested this book from Netgalley as well but from some other bad reviews decided not to give it a try, now I’m for sure glad I didn’t. Quick, read a really good book and cleanse you pallet!

    P.S- have you started/ read the second book in the Coronets and Steel series? I’m about halfway through but keep reading other things. It’s good, but not gripping.