Home / Books / Guest Book Review: Inheritance by Christopher Paolini

Guest Book Review: Inheritance by Christopher Paolini

Today’s guest post is from my friend Diana, who reviewed Inheritance (Book 4) by Christopher Paolini. I didn’t get a chance to review this book myself, and I’m thankful Diana is here to provide you with some great insights!!

Guest Book Review: Inheritance by Christopher Paolini

An avid reader, I have been looking forward to reading Inheritance since the fateful day in September 2008 when I finished Brisingr only to be met with a letter from Mr. Paolini himself informing me that I would need to wait for a final installment to find out what ultimately happens to Saphira and Eragon.

This being said, I think Paolini had a lot to make up for in this book, and this conclusion was set to be the most exciting installment yet. Needless to say, my expectations for this 850 page finale were quite high and there were so many questions running through my head and I wondered how he was going to answer them sufficiently.

Here are some of the questions that I expected to be answered in Inheritance, the final installment and some that I hoped would be answered too.

Inheritance by Christopher Paolini

1How will Eragon and Galbatorix finally face off and to what outcome? A fairly obvious question, I know, but this is what the entire series has focused on, so it was the number one question on my list, considering the build up to this point.

2What is going to happen to Thorn and Murtagh? Will they be rehabilitated? While Murtagh’s character took a turn for the worse in the second book, I cannot help but feel sorry for him and I hope to see him and Thorn freed from Galbatorix’s influence.

3What will happen between Eragon and Arya? Their relationship has been tumultuous and Arya has made it fairly clear that she wants nothing to do with Eragon romantically, but as the series has progressed they seemed to develop a closer bond. Will this bond eventually lead to the relationship that Eragon has been hoping for?

4What happens to Sloan? Does he ever regain his sight? Do Roran and Katrina ever discover that he is still alive?

5There is a green dragon on the cover? Is there another rider or does the final egg hatch? For which side? For who? My guesses: Roran, Arya, or one of the other elves.

6What is the Rock of Kuthian and the Vault of Souls? My guess is that it has something to do with the dragons heart of hearts, or Eldunari, but where is it and how does Eragon find it?

7. What about Elva? Will she help defeat Galbatorix or will she turn against Eragon and Nasuada?

8Where did Angela come from? Why does she know so much? Angela is one of the most mysterious and intriguing characters of the series and I am obsessed with back stories. For instance, although the Dark Knight has been claimed to be one of the best Batman movies to date, it bothered me so much that the Joker did not have a background (while it has been explained to me that this was on purpose, I want to know why he is the way he is so badly!). I have this same obsession with the character of Angela the herbalist.

9In Brisingr, Eragon meets an eccentric old man, Tenga, who is searching for the answer to “the question.” Who is Tenga and what is he searching for? What relevance does this play in the overall plot of the novel?

10Also in Brisingr, Eragon and Saphira bless two women. I have a feeling that they have some role yet to play, and I am curious to know how they will factor into this conclusion.

11To retrieve the material to make his sword, Eragon and Saphira assault the Menoa Tree and she exacts a price from him. Eragon stated that he felt a strange tug in his gut. Which leads to the question of what the Menoa Tree took from him.

Finishing Inheritance was like saying goodbye to an old friend, but an old friend you had not seen in years and were sorely disappointed by how they had changed, which made it even harder to say goodbye. For me, Paolini left too many questions unanswered and left the reader wanting. There was just too much left unsaid.

In Paolini’s defense, he mentioned in his customary letter to the readers that while he is done with Eragon and Saphira’s story, he is planning on returning to Alagaesia, and purposefully left some of the characters’ backgrounds and side stories unexplained purposefully. I get it, the kid needs to make a living, but I am also tired of waiting for answers.

I guarantee I will read whatever he publishes next, but the more he leaves unsaid, the higher my, and I would be willing to bet other readers’, expectations become. It almost seems as though he is setting himself up for failure.

As for the story, the ending was predictable and anti-climatic, if a tad more depressing than I expected. The ending felt rushed, if slightly incomplete, and as I have already stated at length, left the reader wanting more. At times, it seemed as though Paolini glossed over some of the more important aspects of the storyline, but spent too much time describing events that were not integral to the storyline and could have easily been cut out altogether.

I think he may have set himself too strict a goal. Aspiring to write the series in three books, and then in four, he left himself no room to maneuver and it shows. I think he could have done a better job if the series had been five or six books instead of four, but because he gave his readers a promise of three books, and then tricked us, and turned to four, it would have looked terrible had he gotten to the end of Inheritance and simply said, “Hey guys, sorry for doing this again, but I need another book.” He backed himself into the proverbial corner, and Inheritance suffered for it. I just hope he plans better for his future novels.

Griping aside, I still admire Christopher Paolini and the world and characters he created. Writing this series is an amazing accomplishment for someone barely a quarter of a century old. Inheritance was a fun read, despite its flaws, and an enjoyable book. I am interested to see what Paolini puts out next, hopefully sooner rather than later.


Thanks again to Diana for this fabulous review of Inheritance!!

About Lisa Parkin

I'm a hardcore lover of young adult fiction and have been reviewing books since 2011. Other interests include Downton Abbey, heat lightning storms, Harry Potter land and (begrudingly) one orange tabby.
  • http://ems-reviews-books.blogspot.com/ Ems

    Oh dear. Sounds like this reads a bit like Eragon did for me on the first attempt. I thought it felt like some pretty poorly done fan fiction. Ironically, it wasn’t until after I’d seen the movie that I decided to go back and give it another shot. I’m one of those ‘the book is almost always better’ people. I’ve got this one preordered, so hopefully it’ll be worth the price. Love the honest review!

  • Ajihad

    Finishing Inheritance was like saying goodbye to an old friend, but an old friend you had not seen in years and were sorely disappointed by how they had changed, which made it even harder to say goodbye….very apt

  • Melissa Hayden

    I have this one here on the shelf to read. I can’t wait to read it, but it is a sad thing when a series ends. I do look forward to see what Christopher puts out next too. Thank you!

  • Ravenz

    Inheritance was very dull and boring, pages upon pages filled with unimoprtant details and boring storylines. I suffered through this only to complete it and be done. Brisingr was bad enough but this was like meandering through someones attempt through writers block. like, “i can’t think how to end this yet so I will babble on and on until I get an idea..” Eragon became a painful character in Brisingr with all his soul searching and lack of identity, bordering on the rediculous. This is supposed to be the main character and I cant even like him because I can’t find his personality. So glad I borrowed this book and didnt waste the $25 on it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Laura-McGuire/1486906631 Laura McGuire

    I completely agree with you. The ending left me absolutely wanting something more. I am a big fan of Paolini and hope someday to be an author. However this book taught me a lesson, never promise more than what you can give. Also, above all else your goal is to make readers happy. To have them close the book and say, “that was great! I can’t wait for what s/he comes out with next!” This book did not do that for me. There is nothing I hate more than a story that never ends, It just makes me wanna quit reading because I know I’ll never get all my questions answered. Sadly, I know I’ll probably end up reading every other continence of the series; hoping and praying that I’ll finally get the answers I’ve been waiting for. Overall this book left me feeling a tad depressed and a bit frustrated.

  • Pingback: Inheritence- Christopher Paolini |

  • Pingback: Top Ten Series I Haven't Finished | Read. Breathe. Relax. | Ya book reviews and fantasy book reviews